The society would still like to identify those buried in the cemetery in unmarked graves, or in graves with limited info. on the headstone. (See headstone readings below). Please contact info@bcgensoc.com or write the society at P.O. Box 8808, Benton Harbor, MI 49023-8808, with any information about those buried in this cemetery.

The surnames Barnhouse , Dragoo, Knight, McCoy, Tomlinson, and Warfield are found among the headstones. The following are headstone readings from the cemetery, compiled in the late 1970s. The bracketed information is comments by the transcribers or information that has been offered by ancestors.

McCOY CEMETERY 1980

B, N. A. - [no birth or death dates]

B., S. - [no birth or death dates] [Samuel Barnhouse]

B, S. N. - [no birth or death dates] [Samuel Nelson Barnhouse]

Barnhouse, Nancy A., wife of Samuel, d. 14 Jan. 1866

Barnhouse, William H. - [husband of Jacob & Isabelle's granddaughter]

Dragoo, [illegible], wife of Uel - [the first name is Jane]

Dragoo, Christena Jane, daughter of Jacob & Isabell

Dragoo, Isabell, wife of Jacob

Dragoo, Jacob

Dragoo, John F. - [son of Jacob & Isabell]

Dragoo, Peter, son of Jacob and Isabell

K., H. C. [it appears this may be the footstone of Herbert C. Knight]

Knight, Herbert C., son of M. L. & I. - [Melvin & Isabella (Barnhouse) Knight]

McCoy, Catherine, wife of Wm. McCoy

T., L.

Tomlinson, Albert

Tomlinson, Elizabeth M., daughter of A. & L.

Tomlinson, Soyda [possible mispelling], L., wife of Albert

Tomlinson, [illegible name], wife of Benjamin

W., S.

Warfield, R.

[illegible last name], F.

[illegible last name], Libby A.

There are 4 headstone foundations with unlettered pieces of headstones on them, and 2 headstone foundations without headstones.